| Major operators with international and inter-regional footprints such as
Vodafone and Orascom Telecom have announced their intention to deploy mobile
remittance, which they hope will act as a catalyst for the wider adoption
of mWallet-enabled transaction services. |
Despite
the impact of the 2008-2009 global downturn, remittances as a source of
liquidity will likely prove to be resilient, and could potentially play a role
in restoring or increasing prosperity across regions. Whereas the sharp
contraction of credit in the global banking sector has directly and
instantaneously ravaged FDI alongside private debt and equity flows, remittances
to the developing world are slowing down more gradually and indirectly as a
result of declining personal consumption, lay-offs, and lower salaries impacting
the real economy. This adds the resilience of remittances, where migrant workers
will continue sending money to relatives in their countries of origin during
uncertain economic times, albeit at less regular intervals and/or in smaller
amounts.
Mobile Money Transfer is positioned to exercise considerable
transformational effect on developing economies, a crucial factor for wider
world economic growth. Mobile Money also enables financial services and money
transfers - often initiated by urban and international immigrants - to reach
poor people in rural areas. Mobile remittance services will form the first
commercially viable and sustainable opportunity to reach the unbanked with low
cost, no-frills financial services.
Major operators with international
and inter-regional footprints such as Vodafone and Orascom Telecom have
announced their intention to deploy mobile remittance, which they hope will act
as a catalyst for the wider adoption of mWallet-enabled transaction services.
Most importantly, mobile remittance presents a way for these inter-regional
players to further maximise revenue potential through a greater proportion of
their respective footprints, leveraging their assets in Europe and the Middle
East in synergy with those in South Asia, Africa and the Asia Pacific!
.
Reading this exclusive management report will tell you the
following: • What different forms of mobile remittance are available and
expected to appear in the future? • Why is mobile potentially so important to
banking and financial services, as well as economic development? • When will
mobile remittance become a truly global mass market proposition? • How
successful can these service propositions become?
Table of Contents
Executive
Summary E1.
Mobile Remittance and m-transaction - Unexpected Adoption and Benefits for
Developing Economies E2. The short term impact of the global economic
downturn E3. Remittances to support new long term banking direction E4.
Providing Favourable Regulatory Frameworks
1.
Introduction 1.1
What Exactly Is Mobile Remittance? 1.2. Focus of the Report
2.
The Remittance Market 2.1
The Critical Macroeconomic Role of Remittances
Chart 1. Remittances as a Share of National GDP in 2006 2.2 Behind
Global Growth Trends in Remittance Flows
2.2.1 Growth in Global Migration
Chart 2. Growth in Global
Migrant Stocks, 1960-2050
Chart 3. Average Annual
Net Migrants to More Developed Regions
2.2.2 Remittance Flow Growth
Chart 4. Growth of Global
Remittance Flows 1990-2007
&nb! sp; ; Chart 5.
Financial Flows into Developing Economies 1990-2007
2.2.3 Analysis of Flows into Recipient Countries
Table 1. Top 30 Formal
Remittance Receiving Countries 2007
Table 2. Top 30 Formal
Remitter Countries 2007 2.3 Migration Patterns and Remittance
Corridors
Figure 1. Major Bilateral Remittance
Corridors and Estimated Flows, 2007
2.3.1 Growth of the UK-Poland Remittance Corridor
2.3.2 Remittance Corridors and Operator Market Strategy 2.4
Remittances as a stable source of external finance 2.5 The multiplying effect
of remittances: consumption, savings and investment
2.5.1 Enabling additive and transformational approaches to banking
3.
Drivers towards Implementation 3.1
Financial Infrastructure
Chart 6. Market Share of P2P Money
Transfers 2006
3.1.1 Inadequate Servicing of
Remittance by Existing Mechanisms
Table 3. Global and UK
Remittance Transaction Fees Comparison
3.1.2 Poor financial infrastructure in developing economies
3.1.3 Participation in the formal vs. informal economy 3.2 Mobile
Infrastructure
3.2.1 Global Mobile
Penetration
! ; &
nbsp; Chart 7. Global Telecoms Subscriber Growth,
1982-2013
Chart 8. African Mobile Subscriber Growth 1999-2013
Chart 9. Asian Mobile Subscriber
Growth 1999-2013
3.2.2 Technological
Developments
3.2.2.1 The Development
of M-transaction
3.2.2.2
Convergence
3.2.2.3 Convergence
Embraces Mobile Transaction
3.2.2.2 Low-cost
handsets
3.2.2.3 Mobile Subscriber Growth in Emerging Markets
Chart 10. Top
Ten Countries for Net Additional Subscribers 2007
3.2.2.4 SMS
Banking
Figure 2.
Basic SMS banking transaction flow
3.2.2.4.1
Prime Disadvantages of SMS banking
3.2.2.5 STK-enabled
Mobile Transaction
3.2.2.6 IVR Banking
Service Delivery
3.2.2.7 USSD/USSD2
3.2.2.8 WAP Service
Delivery
3.2.2.9 Service Delivery
via J2ME Apps
3.2.2.10 mWallet
4.
Mobile Remittance: Operator-Side Types of Implementation 4.1
Business Models
Figure 4. Mobile Remittance Value
Chain
4.1.1 Mobile Operator as Bearer
Channel Provider
Figure 5. MNO as
Bearer-only Business Model
4.1.2 Mobile Operator as Bearer and
Banking Application Host
Figure 6. MNO Banking
Application Host Business Model
4.1.3 Integrating Banks/Financial
Institutions into Mobile Operator Hosted Platforms
&! nbsp;&nb sp;
Figure 7. Business Model for an MNO as a Banking Hub
Figure 8. Topology of the
MNO Banking Hub Model
4.1.4 MNO Adoption of Financial
Institution Status
Figure 9.
Financially-licensed MNO model with MNO positioned as beneficiary
Figure 9.
Financially-licensed MNO model with MNO positioned as remitter
4.1.5 Summary of MNO Business Model Options 4.2. Business Model
Options for Financial Institutions 4.3 Service Models
4.3.1 mWallet to mWallet
Scenario 1.
mWallet-to-mWallet transaction
4.3.2. mWallet to
Cash
Scenario 2. mWallet-to-Cash transaction
4.3.3 Cash to mWallet
Scenario 3.
Cash-to-mWallet transaction
5.
Financial and Mobile Industry Convergence: Control Points and Requirements in
Implementation 5.1
Regulatory
5.1.1 Addressing Boundaries between
financial and telecoms regulatory frameworks
5.1.2. Aligning Developing Economy Mobile Remittance Models with KYC and
AML/CFT Regulations
5.1.3. Developing Economy Mobile
Remittance Models and the Application of Prudential Regulation
5.1.3. Developing Economy Mobile Remittance Models and Access to Clearing
Systems
5.1.4 Formalising Remittance
Flows 5.2. Transaction Processing
6.
Mobile Operator and Financial Institution Partnerships: Mobile Remittance Case
Studies and
Emerging
Developments
6.1.
Smart Telecom mWallet Services, Philippines
Chart 11. Smart Money users as Proportion of Subs
6.1.1 Smart Padala Remittance: 4 years of success
Tables 4a and 4b. Smart
Padala Remittance Partners and Locations Overseas 6.2. Globe Telecom,
Philippines
6.2.1 GXI - Globe's M-Commerce
Subsidiary 6.3. Vodafone's Strategies
6.3.1 Safaricom and M-PESA: m-transaction as a precursor to wider
cross-border mobile remittance
&nbs! p; 6.3.1.1
M-PESA Adoption Curve
Chart 12.
M-PESA Adoption, April 2007-March2008
6.3.1.2 M-PESA Adoption
Drivers
6.3.1.4 The M-PESA
Service Model
6.3.1.5 M-PESA Expansion
and International Implementation by Vodafone
Figure 10.
Advertisement for M-PESA
6.3.1.6 Delays and
Barriers for the International Implementation of M-PESA
&n! bsp; 6.3.2
Vodafone and Citigroup/Citibank global agreement 6.5. Bharti Airtel and Western Union
Pilot Project 6.6. The GSM Association Mobile Money Transfer (MMT)
Initiative
6.6.1 MMT: Attempt at creating a
Multilateral Remittance Framework
Table 5. Options for the
Implementation of Multilateral MMT Hub Platforms
6.6.2 Partnerships
6.6.2.1 GSMA-Western
Union Partnership
6.6.2.2 GSMA-MasterCard
Partnership
6.6.2.3 GSMA-Western
Union-Smart
6.6.2.4 GSMA-Western
Union-RBS Group-Belgacom ICS HomeSend platform
&!
nbsp;&nb sp; 6.6.2.5 GSMA-Visa
6.6.2.6 Western
Union-Orascom mobile money transfer pilot 6.7 NatWest-PKO Bank Polski 6.8
Visa-US Bank mobile money transfer pilot 6.9 Deutsche Bank mobile payments
service 6.10 !dea Cellular, Tata Communications, HSBC India & Etisalat
UAE joint pilot project
7.
Remittance: Vendor Profiles 7.1
Utiba 7.2 aKos Technology Corporation 7.3 Cointel 7.4 Monitise 7.5
GFG Group 7.6 Sybase 7.7 Paybox 7.8 eServGlobal 7.9
mTranZact 7.10 Overview of M-Commerce Vendors in Remittance
7.10.1 Licensing Vendor Business Models
7.10.2 ASP Vendor Business Models
7.10.3 Suitability
8.
Conclusion 8.1
A necessity for economic development equals high consequential take-up 8.2
The need for regulatory harmonisation and accommodation 8.3. Standardisation
as an achievable goal 8.4. Which form of mobile remittance will emerge as the
most common? 8.5. The Danger of the Two Tier Mobile Economy 8.6.
Forecasts: Deriving growth from global recovery beyond 2010
Chart 13. Global remittance growth forecast
Chart 14. Comparison of Forecasts for Remittance Channels By
Value
Chart 15. Forecasts for Remittance
Channel Volume
Table 6. Operator revenues generated
from transaction costs
8.6.1. Greatest Impact: Asia and
Africa
Chart 16. Comparative Mobile
Remittance Forecast for Recipient Cou! ntries
Table 7. Forecast for Mobile Remittance Transaction Volumes per Country
(US$million)
8.6.1. Minimal Impact in Latin
America and Eastern Europe
Companies
& Organistations listed in report
aKos
Technology
Aktel
Alliance
& Leicester
AT&T
Belgacom
ICS
Bharti
Airtel
Cable
& Wireless
Citigroup
ClearTalk
Wireless
COAI
Cointel
CSL
Cybertalk
Limited
Dahaabshil
Deloitte
Deutsche
Bank
DFID
Dialog
Digicel
Du
Enitel
eServGlobal
Etisalat
EU
Financial
Services Authority
Fundamo
GFG
Group
Globe
Telecom
Global
Peso Express
Grameenphone
GXI
HSBC
Hutchison
3G
ICSL
Nigeria
!dea
Cellular
IMF
Indosat
Inter-American
Development Bank
Lari
Exchange
Lebara
Mobile
LG
Electronics
Life
Link
Lycatel
Luup
MasterCard
Maxis
MiPay
Mobilink
MoneyGram
Monitise
Motorola
MTC
Bahrain
MTN
mTranZact
Nairobi
Stock Exchange
NatWest
Nokia
Orange
Orascom
Telecom
Paybox
Pera
Padala
Pinoy
Express
PKO
Bank Polski
Polkomtel
Royal
Bank of Scotland
Safaricom
SingTel
Smart
Communications
Softbank
Sony-Ericsson
Swisscom
Sybase
Tata
Communications
Telefonica
Telenor
Tesco
Mobile
TIM
TMN
Touch
Mobile
Travelex
Turkceli
Ulster
Bank
UNCTAD
United
Nations
US
Bank
Utiba
Vigo
VimpelCom
Virgin
Mobile
Visa
Vodacom
Vodafone
Western
Union
World
Bank
Zantel
|